By Joyce Ekeh
Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court in Abuja, Thursday, recused himself from the N10.27 billion fraud trial involving Ali Bello, nephew of immediate past Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, following concerns over alleged tampering with an exhibit already admitted in evidence.
Bello is facing a 10-count charge filed by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, EFCC, alongside his alleged accomplice, Dauda Sulaiman.
The judge said the unresolved issue surrounding the alleged alteration of evidence could affect the court’s consideration of the defendants’ no-case submission and potentially lead to perceptions of bias.
He consequently directed that the case file be returned to the Chief Judge for reassignment.
The development came as the court was scheduled to hear the defendants’ no-case submission after the EFCC closed its case on June 2, following evidence from 17 witnesses.
The defendants had maintained that the prosecution failed to establish a prima facie case requiring them to enter a defence.
Justice Omotosho said the security agencies had yet to submit an investigative report on the alleged tampering, about seven months after the issue was raised.
He said the evidence in question was important to the case because the court would have to consider it in determining whether the defendants had a case to answer.
The judge recalled that the court had earlier directed the Department of State Services, DSS, and the Nigeria Police Force, NPF, to investigate allegations involving a court registrar, Mr Nasiru Onimisi Zubairu, and Sulaiman.
The investigation followed allegations that some contents of Exhibits N and O, including WhatsApp messages extracted from a mobile phone admitted in evidence, had been deleted.
The judge had earlier disclosed that the registrar told him that Sulaiman allegedly approached him and requested that some WhatsApp messages be deleted from the phone, with an alleged promise to provide him with accommodation.
The registrar was subsequently called before the court, where he gave his account of the alleged encounter.
According to Zubairu, Sulaiman approached him after learning of his accommodation difficulty and allegedly asked him to delete some WhatsApp messages contained in the exhibits.
“He then asked me to delete some information, some WhatsApp messages in the exhibits, and promised to give me a house,” the registrar told the court.
The court also heard from the EFCC investigation officer, Muhammed Audu Abubakar, who was asked to examine the phone and compare its contents with the extracts already tendered as exhibits.
Abubakar told the court that some messages appearing in the extracts were no longer found on the phone.
He identified several gaps in the WhatsApp conversations, including messages allegedly exchanged between December 2020 and February 2022.
The prosecution subsequently asked the court to order further investigation into the matter.
EFCC counsel, Mr Rotimi Oyedepo, SAN, told the court that the prosecution had concerns about the integrity of Exhibit N and sought orders relating to the defendant’s bail and forensic examination of the exhibit.
“My Lord, there is a very urgent and irresistible suspicion that Exhibit N, which contains crucial evidence, has been tampered with.
“We apply that Your Lordship grant an order revoking the bail of the defendant and also order a forensic investigation of Exhibit N,” Oyedepo submitted.
Defence lawyers expressed concern over the development and urged the court to await the outcome of a forensic investigation.
Explaining his decision to recuse himself, Justice Omotosho said whichever decision he reached in the case could be subjected to interpretations arising from the unresolved evidence issue.
He said it was therefore in the interest of justice for another judge to handle the matter.
Earlier, the court had played a recording of the registrar’s account in open court, following which the registrar was invited to personally explain his account of the alleged interaction with Sulaiman.
In the charge marked FHC/ABJ/CR/550/2022, the EFCC alleges that Bello and Sulaiman withdrew N10,270,556,800 from the Kogi State treasury and allegedly delivered the money to a Bureau de Change operator, Rabiu Tafada, in Abuja, for safekeeping or conversion into foreign currencies for personal gain.
The defendants have denied the allegations, and the case remains before the Federal High Court.
